| Year | Pick | Player | Position | College |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1943 | 288 | Bob Ray | B | Wisconsin |
| 1944 | 313 | Bob Butchofsky | B | Texas A&M |
| 1945 | 318 | Ham Nichols | G | Rice |
| 1946 | 286 | Al Sparlis | G | UCLA |
| 1947 | 280 | Jerry Carle | B | Northwestern |
| 1948 | 281 | Clarence McGeary | DT | North Dakota St. |
| 1950 | 381 | Ray Mallouf | QB | SMU |
| 1951 | 352 | Ed Withers | B | Wisconsin |
| 1952 | 351 | Jack Fulkerson | T | Southern Miss |
| 1953 | 356 | Al Barry | G | USC |
| 1954 | 351 | Terry Campbell | B | Washington St. |
| 1955 | 352 | Bob Saia | B | Tulane |
| 1956 | 355 | Rod Hermes | QB | Beloit |
| 1958 | 350 | John Peters | T | Houston |
| 1959 | 349 | Dick Emerich | T | West Chester |