| Year | Pick | Player | Position | College |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1943 | 278 | Dick Thornally | T | Wisconsin |
| 1944 | 302 | Paul Paladino | G | Arkansas |
| 1945 | 307 | Jim Evans | E | Idaho |
| 1946 | 276 | Francis Saunders | T | Clemson |
| 1947 | 271 | Ray Sellers | E | Georgia |
| 1948 | 271 | John (Pep) Panelli | B | Notre Dame |
| 1950 | 368 | Ben Zaranka | E | Kentucky |
| 1951 | 341 | Ralph Fieler | E | Miami (FL) |
| 1952 | 340 | Bill Stratton | B | Lewis University |
| 1953 | 344 | Henry O'Brien | G | Boston Col. |
| 1954 | 339 | Jerry Dufek | T | St. Norbert |
| 1955 | 341 | Sam Pino | B | Boston Univ. |
| 1956 | 344 | Vester Newcomb | C | Southwest JC (MS) |
| 1957 | 340 | Howie Dare | B | Maryland |
| 1958 | 339 | Bob Haynes | T | Sam Houston St. |
| 1959 | 337 | Jack Flara | B | Pittsburgh |