| Year | Pick | Player | Position | College |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1943 | 268 | Bud Hasse | E | Northwestern |
| 1944 | 291 | A.B. Howard | E | Mississippi St. |
| 1945 | 296 | Jim Thompson | B | Washington St. |
| 1946 | 266 | Joe Campbell | E | Holy Cross |
| 1947 | 262 | Jerrell Baxter | T | North Carolina |
| 1948 | 261 | Don Sharp | C | Tulsa |
| 1950 | 355 | Herm Hering | B | Rutgers |
| 1951 | 330 | Bill Ayre | B | Abilene Christian |
| 1952 | 327 | Billy Barrett | B | Notre Dame |
| 1953 | 332 | Zack Jordan | B | Colorado |
| 1954 | 327 | Evan Slonac | B | Michigan St. |
| 1955 | 329 | Jack Spears | T | Chattanooga |
| 1956 | 332 | Bobby Lance | QB | Florida |
| 1957 | 327 | Dave Herbold | G | Minnesota |
| 1958 | 326 | Dave Crowell | G | Washington St. |
| 1959 | 325 | Jerry Epps | G | West Texas A&M |