| Year | Pick | Player | Position | College |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1943 | 258 | Pete Susick | B | Washington |
| 1944 | 280 | Al Grubaugh | T | Nebraska |
| 1945 | 285 | Bill Chestnut | B | Kansas |
| 1946 | 256 | Ed Holtsinger | B | Georgia Tech |
| 1947 | 250 | Bob Palladino | B | Notre Dame |
| 1948 | 251 | Stan Gorski | E | |
| 1950 | 342 | Bill Osborne | B | Nevada |
| 1951 | 316 | Bob Bossons | C | Georgia Tech |
| 1952 | 316 | l.D. Russell | B | SMU |
| 1953 | 320 | Jim McConaughey | E | Houston |
| 1954 | 315 | Hosea Sims | E | Marquette |
| 1955 | 317 | Bob Peringer | E | Washington St. |
| 1956 | 320 | Dick Kolian | E | Wisconsin |
| 1957 | 316 | Marty Booher | T | Wisconsin |
| 1958 | 315 | Neil Habig | C | Purdue |
| 1959 | 313 | Timmy Brown | RB | Ball St. |