| Year | Pick | Player | Position | College |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1943 | 248 | George Makris | G | Wisconsin |
| 1944 | 269 | Ray Jordan | B | North Carolina |
| 1945 | 274 | Nestor Blanco | G | Colorado Mines |
| 1946 | 246 | John Norton | B | Washington |
| 1947 | 241 | Herm Lubker | E | Arkansas |
| 1948 | 241 | Aubrey Allen | T | Colorado |
| 1950 | 329 | Claude Radtke | E | Lawrence |
| 1951 | 305 | Bill Miller | T | Ohio St. |
| 1952 | 303 | Charlie Stokes | T | Tennessee |
| 1953 | 308 | George Bozanic | B | USC |
| 1954 | 303 | Ralph Baierl | T | Maryland |
| 1955 | 305 | Jim Jennings | DE | Missouri |
| 1956 | 308 | Dick Goehe | T | Mississippi |
| 1957 | 303 | Buddy Bass | E | Duke |
| 1958 | 302 | Esker Harris | G | UCLA |
| 1959 | 301 | Ken Higginbotham | E |