| Year | Pick | Player | Position | College |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1943 | 238 | Gene Bierhaus | E | Minnesota |
| 1944 | 258 | Len Liss | T | Marquette |
| 1945 | 263 | Nolan Luhn | E | Tulsa |
| 1946 | 236 | Chick Davidson | T | Cornell |
| 1947 | 232 | Fred Redeker | B | Cincinnati |
| 1948 | 231 | Stan Heath | QB | Nevada |
| 1949 | 243 | Frank Lambright | G | Arkansas |
| 1950 | 316 | Frank Waters | B | Michigan St. |
| 1951 | 294 | Charlie Monte | B | Hillsdale |
| 1952 | 292 | Charlie LaPradd | T | Florida |
| 1953 | 296 | Ike Jones | E | UCLA |
| 1954 | 291 | John Smalley | T | Alabama |
| 1955 | 293 | Nate Borden | DE | Indiana |
| 1956 | 296 | Franz Koeneke | E | Minnesota |
| 1957 | 292 | Jerry Johnson | T | St. Norbert |
| 1958 | 291 | Larry Plenty | B | Boston Col. |
| 1959 | 289 | Leroy Hardee | B | Florida A&M |