| Year | Pick | Player | Position | College |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1943 | 228 | George Zellick | E | Oregon St. |
| 1944 | 247 | Pete DeMaria | G | Purdue |
| 1945 | 252 | Lloyd Baxter | C | SMU |
| 1946 | 226 | Maurice Stacy | B | Washington |
| 1947 | 220 | Herb St. John | G | Georgia |
| 1948 | 221 | Clyde Biggers | T | Catawba |
| 1949 | 234 | Jimmy Ford | B | Tulsa |
| 1950 | 303 | Don Delph | B | Dayton |
| 1951 | 280 | Dick Christie | B | Nebraska-Omaha |
| 1952 | 279 | John Schuetzner | E | South Carolina |
| 1953 | 284 | Jim Haslam | T | Tennessee |
| 1954 | 279 | Marv Tennefoss | E | Stanford |
| 1955 | 281 | Charley Bryant | G | Nebraska |
| 1956 | 284 | Don Wilson | C | Rice |
| 1957 | 279 | Charlie Leyendecker | T | SMU |
| 1958 | 278 | John Jereck | T | Detroit Mercy |
| 1959 | 277 | Joe Hergert | LB | Florida |