| Year | Pick | Player | Position | College |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1943 | 218 | Jug Bennett | G | Hardin-Simmons |
| 1944 | 236 | John Wesley Perry | B | Duke |
| 1945 | 241 | Bob Gilmore | B | Washington |
| 1946 | 216 | Andy Kosmac | C | LSU |
| 1947 | 211 | Ron Sockolov | T | California |
| 1948 | 211 | Fred Kling | B | Missouri |
| 1949 | 223 | Bill Kelley | E | Texas Tech |
| 1950 | 290 | George Mattey | G | Ohio St. |
| 1951 | 269 | Tubba Chamberlain | G | Wisconsin–Eau Claire |
| 1952 | 268 | Frank Kapral | G | Michigan St. |
| 1953 | 272 | Bill Murray | E | American Int. |
| 1954 | 267 | Clint Sathrum | B | St. Olaf |
| 1955 | 269 | Elton Shaw | T | LSU |
| 1956 | 272 | Jesse Birchfield | G | Duke |
| 1957 | 268 | John Symank | DB | Florida |
| 1958 | 267 | Jack Ashton | G | South Carolina |
| 1959 | 265 | Ben Lawver | T | Lewis & Clark |