| Year | Pick | Player | Position | College |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1939 | 199 | Bill Gunther | B | Santa Clara |
| 1940 | 199 | Henry Luebcke | T | Iowa |
| 1941 | 196 | Bruno Malinowski | B | Holy Cross |
| 1942 | 199 | Woody Adams | T | TCU |
| 1943 | 208 | Mark Hoskins | B | Wisconsin |
| 1944 | 225 | Cliff Anderson | E | Minnesota |
| 1945 | 230 | Fred Nielson | T | |
| 1946 | 206 | Howie Brown | G | Indiana |
| 1947 | 202 | Maurice (Tex) Reilly | B | Colorado |
| 1948 | 201 | Don (Red) Anderson | B | Rice |
| 1949 | 214 | John Kordick | B | USC |
| 1950 | 277 | Chuck Beatty | C | Penn St. |
| 1951 | 258 | Art Felker | E | Marquette |
| 1952 | 255 | Karl Kluckhohn | E | Colgate |
| 1953 | 260 | Bill Turnbeaugh | T | Auburn |
| 1954 | 255 | Willie Buford | T | Morgan St. |
| 1955 | 257 | Bill Brunner | B | Arkansas Tech |
| 1956 | 260 | Johnny Popson | B | Furman |
| 1957 | 255 | Ronnie Quillian | QB | Tulane |
| 1958 | 254 | Dick Maggard | B | Col. of Idaho |
| 1959 | 253 | Charlie Anderson | E | Drake |