| Year | Pick | Player | Position | College |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1939 | 194 | Willard Hofer | B | Notre Dame |
| 1940 | 194 | Vince Eichler | B | Cornell |
| 1941 | 192 | Joe Bailey | C | Kentucky |
| 1942 | 194 | Henry Woronicz | E | Boston Col. |
| 1943 | 198 | Lloyd Wasserbach | T | Wisconsin |
| 1944 | 214 | Jim Cox | G | Stanford |
| 1945 | 219 | Warren Fuller | E | Fordham |
| 1946 | 196 | Ralph Grant | B | Bucknell |
| 1947 | 190 | Bob West | B | Colorado |
| 1948 | 191 | Herb St. John | G | Georgia |
| 1949 | 203 | Ken Kranz | DB | Wisconsin–Milwaukee |
| 1950 | 264 | Gene Evans | B | Wisconsin |
| 1951 | 244 | Art Edling | E | Minnesota |
| 1952 | 244 | Herb Zimmerman | G | TCU |
| 1953 | 248 | Bob Conway | B | Alabama |
| 1954 | 243 | Art Liebscher | B | Pacific |
| 1955 | 245 | Lavell Isbell | T | Houston |
| 1956 | 248 | Hal O'Brien | B | SMU |
| 1957 | 244 | Chuck Mehrer | T | Missouri |
| 1958 | 243 | Jerry Kershner | T | Oregon |
| 1959 | 241 | Dave Smith | FB | Ripon |