| Year | Pick | Player | Position | College |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1939 | 189 | Charlie Schultz | T | Minnesota |
| 1940 | 189 | Jim Reeder | T | Illinois |
| 1941 | 186 | Jimmy Strausbaugh | HB | Ohio St. |
| 1942 | 189 | Horace (Deacon) Young | B | SMU |
| 1943 | 188 | Eddie Forrest | G | Santa Clara |
| 1944 | 203 | Bob Johnson | C | Purdue |
| 1945 | 208 | Bill Prentice | B | Santa Clara |
| 1946 | 186 | Bill DeRosa | B | Boston Col. |
| 1947 | 181 | Brad Ecklund | C | Oregon |
| 1948 | 181 | Floyd Thomas | C | Arkansas |
| 1949 | 194 | Larry Cooney | B | Penn St. |
| 1950 | 251 | Jim Howe | B | Kentucky |
| 1951 | 233 | Dick Johnson | T | Virginia |
| 1952 | 231 | Chuck Boerio | LB | Illinois |
| 1953 | 236 | John Harville | B | TCU |
| 1954 | 231 | Lowell Herbert | G | Pacific |
| 1955 | 233 | Carl Bolt | B | Southern Miss |
| 1955 | 236 | Bob Antkowiak | E | Bucknell |
| 1956 | 236 | Clyde Letbetter | T | Baylor |
| 1957 | 231 | Percy Oliver | G | Illinois |
| 1958 | 230 | John DuBose | B | |
| 1959 | 229 | Charley Sample | B | Arkansas |
| 1960 | 233 | Gilmer Lewis | T | Oklahoma |
| 1961 | 278 | Ray Ratkowski | HB | Notre Dame |
| 1962 | 280 | Mike Snodgrass | C | Western Michigan |
| 1963 | 280 | Bobby Brezina | HB | Houston |
| 1964 | 279 | Bill Curry | C | Georgia Tech |
| 1965 | 276 | Jim Chandler | FB | Benedictine |
| 1966 | 304 | Ed Maras | E | South Dakota St. |