| Year | Pick | Player | Position | College |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1939 | 169 | Frank Balazs | FB | Iowa |
| 1940 | 169 | Jim Gillette | HB | Virginia |
| 1941 | 166 | Heige Pukema | G | Minnesota |
| 1942 | 169 | Bob Ingalls | C | Michigan |
| 1943 | 168 | Jim Powers | T | |
| 1944 | 181 | Hugh Cox | B | North Carolina |
| 1945 | 186 | Frank Hazard | G | Nebraska |
| 1946 | 166 | Boyd Morse | E | Arizona |
| 1947 | 160 | Jim Goodman | T | Indiana |
| 1948 | 161 | Ken Balge | E | Michigan St. |
| 1949 | 174 | Floyd Lewis | G | SMU |
| 1950 | 225 | Arnie Galiffa | QB | Army |
| 1951 | 208 | Ed Petela | B | Boston Col. |
| 1952 | 207 | Howard Tisdale | T | S.F. Austin |
| 1953 | 212 | Jim Philbee | B | Bradley |
| 1954 | 207 | Emery Barnes | DE | Oregon |
| 1955 | 209 | Doyle Nix | DB | SMU |
| 1956 | 212 | Stan Intihar | E | Cornell |
| 1957 | 207 | Credell Green | B | Washington |
| 1958 | 206 | Chuck Strid | G | Syracuse |
| 1959 | 205 | Dick Nearents | T | East. Washington |
| 1960 | 209 | Royce Whittington | T | Louisiana |
| 1961 | 250 | Arthur Sims | B | Texas A&M |
| 1962 | 252 | Bob Joiner | QB | Presbyterian |
| 1963 | 252 | Luis Hernandez | G | Texas-El Paso |
| 1964 | 251 | Mike Hicks | G | Marshall |
| 1965 | 248 | Jeff White | E | Texas Tech |
| 1966 | 274 | Jim Jones | DE | Nebraska-Omaha |